Can one or or all comment on the validity of my approach?(1) Used 500 days of calibration data for parameter estimation of a GARCH(1,1) process and used best fit parameters to estimate future vol over a subsequent data set of 2500 days. (2) Calculated the rolling n-day vol (equally weighted) using n equal to a variety of observation lengths from one month (n=21) to five years (n=1260).(3) I then regressed the GARCH(1,1) estimate as well as the n-day vol estimates in (2) (X variable) on the future n-day vol (same intervals as in (2)) (Y variable) lagged such that the X and Y estimates relied on adjacent but completely independent data (ie, X as GARCH(1,1) used data 1-500 for calibration and first data point in series, Y as 60-day vol used data 501-560 for first data point in Y-series).(4) I asserted that because the GARCH(1,1) estimate using 500 days of calibration data had higher regression coeffs and t-stats than any of the regressions run using n-day vol for any n (for argument's sake, assume this was universally the case, though GARCH did in fact have lower coefficients for regressions on some future n-day vol lengths), that GARCH(1,1) had superior predictive power than simple rolling volatility.Boss counter-asserted that my statement was flawed since the GARCH estimate relied on 500 days of data while certain of the rolling vol estimates as predictors relied on less data. Thus, in order to assess GARCH's benefit any GARCH estimate regression would need to be compared ONLY to its corresponding rolling vol regression (ie, 40-day rolling vol as predictor versus GARCH(1,1) using 40 days for calibration data). Certainly, I can see how he could say that, but it seems to me that 'apples-to-apples' in this case isn't feasible since the GARCH estimate is fundamentally different than a simple standard deviation calculation. Thus, my assessment is valid since we'd never try to fit a GARCH model using only 20 days of data and GARCH using 500 days did better than any of the rolling vol estimates.
Last edited by CTD
on November 3rd, 2008, 11:00 pm, edited 1 time in total.