December 24th, 2003, 8:04 am
Two completely diffrent books...Haug gives u a ready to use collection of (mostly closed) formulae for many exotic options...Clelow-Strickland was (and maybe is) one of my favourite book ever, the real breakthrough book which has shown how derivatives models can be implemented in practice by fitting them to real market data and so forth...the part on trees is really good and the part on short rate models, although not very complte from a theoretical point of view, is a wonderfull source to get a flavour of all the issues involved in costructing interest rate trees and valuing european and american derivatives..A must buy...i think a book comparable to Clelow-Strickland is Brandimarte's "Numerical Methods in Finance"..another nice book, more general then CS and more focused on the underlyng engine (Montecarlo, PDE numerical schemes, optimization..). Haug is then comparable to Zhang..Zhang is a good book, but unfortunately still plenty of typos and without spreadsheets...Haug's book comes with nice spreadsheets, which can help you learning VBA.hope it helps,S