September 6th, 2004, 9:10 pm
QuoteOriginally posted by: daveangelFor every seller there is a buyer - so someone is paying for those options. I think the plummeting VIX is a function of the fact that the markets have gone essentially nowhere. Sector rotation is also helping to increase the dispersion. There is enough belief/hope in the recovery that cyclical are still holding up, surging oil is helping some of the energies, a moderately stable bond market is taking the pressure off the banks. There are still a fair number of people who believe in tech and keep buying those stocks on the dips. We are all in a wait and see mode re the US pres elections.Thanks Dave-My mild response to your statement that "for every seller there is a buyer" is that if comparatively more hedge funds have a preference for naked spreading (or covered writing) lately, then isn't one of the functions of a market maker to supply liquidity to the overall OEX market and to accommodate those recent trends in consumer preferences?My point, perhaps poorly made, is that in a sense the buyers and sellers can have different preferences in such a scenario. The preference of the institution (the sellers) is to somehow suck some yield out of a sideways market. But the preference of at least some market makers in purchasing those same OEXs is to supply liquidity and to subsequently hedge their positions rationally.And in that sense I was thinking that some of the information contained in lowered VIX valuation might also reflect increased selling pressure for those particular OEX options reflected in the VIX index.To some extent, this reflects my bias and strong sentiment that I would much rather sell premium than buy it. It's kind of a personal thing, but I just don't like buying time premium and haven't done so in decades. So perhaps my fear is that others are seeing the "wisdom" of my approach and that this bias and mistaken assumption is coloring my perceptions.Consider the following scenario. Ten friends of mine and I each have 70 million dollars to work with. All of us decide to short 10,000 OEX calls at the money every day for a week. These orders are placed in large blocks to make it interesting.My belief is that I think we could knock down the bid prices just a bit on these at the moneys, thereby reducing the value of the VIX. Am I mistaken? What if we had more cash?Restated, is it possible that prices of the VIX reflect supply and demand pressures on the underlying options as well as volatility alone?As a market maker, if I keep getting orders to sell 3000 at the money OEXs at the bid price, doesn't that act as somewhat of an incentive for me to lower my bid price?Thanks for responding, I do very much respect your opinion and value your response. I'm just trying to explain some of these numbers I'm seeing.Matthew
Last edited by
mdubuque on September 5th, 2004, 10:00 pm, edited 1 time in total.