December 27th, 2006, 10:32 pm
Suppose that side C loses all their members before side J. Then count separately the cases for the number of losses by side J. There is exactly one way for J to lose zero members. There are 7 ways for J to lose one member (before any of the seven members that C loses). There are exactly (8 choose 2) ways for J to lose two members (this is the number of ways of ordering the first six members of C, and the two losing members of J). Then (9 choose 3) ways for J to lose three members, and so on up to J losing six members. Thus, the total number of ways in which C can lose is(6 choose 0) + (7 choose 1) + (8 choose 2) + ... + (12 choose 6) = 1710Double this to also account for the number of ways in which J can lose, and you get 3420. It's easy how to see to extend this to n being something other than 7, and in particular n = 2 works out as 2((1 choose 0) + (2 choose 1)) = 6, as desired.