April 17th, 2008, 3:02 pm
I have not used BK and can only give general comments.BK has some strange features, like the expected bank balance going to infinity for a finite maturity.The two methods are similar in spirit, with the deterministic shift resembling the shifts of the HW tree to match the curve.The desirable feature of SSRD is the jump, although it might produce some unintuitive ATM-forward implied volatilities in my experience. In addition, working with two or more processes can cause problems, as independent jumps will kill the correlation. Also, if the credit spread curve is very steep, then the shift will somewhat dominate the diffusion part.BK will produce more extreme events without the need for a jump, since the lognormal will have a heavier tail than the chi-square.Kyriakos