August 8th, 2005, 9:16 am
people may or may not agree with the war in Iraq.......no-one says that we deserve itObviously you haven't quite met enough people ?Presumably some people think that, else it would not happen...Human justice is a statistical term. Bombings, be they of Hiroshima or London do get some of the "right" people. So does a court of law. Innocent people get sent to jail or executed, so do civillians with on reason under any logic or moral cause when you try to punish and persuade them this way.Thus you must decide what your acceptable error rate is. ....How does bombing london further anyone's cause....???We're social animals. Forget the arts graduate crap that most war is hate. People crave the approval of others, and desire to improve their status with them.Suicide bombers are thus people who just are too emotionally weak to risk losing the approval of their peer group. They will say they "care" about Iraq, yet we observe that none appear tb be from the quite large set of of Iraqis who are in Europe and America. Weak people need a cause to give their lives the meaning they lack, and they need an excuse for the disparity for the success they wishfor their lives, and what they achieve.Short versio, they're showing off to their mates.Young males of all cultures do this. They try riding the roof of a train, take drugs they don't enjoy, drive cars in heroically stupid ways, and pick fights with people for no benefit to themselves other than to improve their status.To this we must add the traditional incompetence of Arabs at war.Too much of this culture is based upon peer approval, a problem Europeans had as recently as the 1940s, and never completely eradicated. I commend to you On the Psychology of Military Incompetence which shows how analagous flaws in British military "thinking" cost the lives of many soliders.Religion makes this worse.It squares the set of objectives. If you want to achieve a goal, you tend to have to do things that you find objectionable. This may involve pain to innocents or yourself. However if you are deeply religious, amny of the things you might find useful are forbidden to you, or when done are so clumsy because of your distaste that you screw them up.In Mr. Dixon's book, Britain was the top dog in techological innovation for a long time, but this was squandered by the Army & Navy because they felt that many advances were outside their tradition.Although it is a long time since Christianity had any real effect on the British army, the love of horses seems to have filled that niche. We find weapons rejected in the 20th century because they couldn't work with cavalry, or worse competed with budgets for horses. Indeed even after WWI there were prolonged periods where more was spent on horses than tanks. The Imperial British Army and a bunch of losers with home made bombs look very different. But they suffered from the same core defect. Keeping the approval of others wa more important than the objective.Any fool could work out that Tony Blair would instantly become more popular, indeed there is now quite a lot of talk of him not resiging as he promised, but staying on.That's not a "British" thing, but a human thing, as we saw with Bush after 9/11, and Iran after it was attacked by Iraq, and any number of attacks. People rally round the leader.We're not up against very competent people here.Look at the ways they were caught.Using relatives phones and homes. Carrying documents that allowed the police to track back. Travelling in groups to commit the attacks. Not having safe houses. No personal weapons.No investment in training time so that they could put up omre than a fight. Why weren't their source locations booby trapped ?Common to all the Abrahamic religions is a big hole. No where are you told that one day you will appear before God and he will ask "why the fuck didn't you think this through ?, are you stupid or what ?"It's all about doing what your heart tells you, and things will work out well in the end.
Last edited by
DominicConnor on August 7th, 2005, 10:00 pm, edited 1 time in total.