March 11th, 2004, 5:54 pm
QuoteOriginally posted by: matthewcrobertsAs an outsider living in the US (but one who is quite familiar with UK politics and government), it really does seem that you guys here are trying your damndest to recreate an aristocracy and a hereditary monarchy. Given the egalitarian and meritocratic principles that people here seem to hold dear, this does seem rather strange.Read DeTocqueville. America has been strange since its inception. Examples abound. While the fate of the US is more tightly bound to the productivity of its human capital, it is likewise often quite anti-intellectual. Its an odd place, full of contradictions, and the worst of nations, except for all the others... Matt.Personally, I'd disagree strongly with the last statement. I feel here that I have so many fewer freedoms than I enjoy at home. No matter how much US citizens claim to the the "most free", it simply is not true. And repeating (even chanting) it, simply does not make it so.I'm afraid that offsetting the very friendly nature, and general acceptance for others, this is a nation obsessed with petty rules, that most everyone seems happy to follow without question. The purpose of the rules seems to have long been forgotten, but adherence is mandatory. Asking "why" is met with a blank look, and an "It's the law" response. Questioning is all too often met with a "Well, you can either love it or leave it".I do like it here, a lot, but I feel stifled, coralled, observed, suspected, and distrusted everywhere I go.Americans having pride in their country is a good thing. Them being blind to its faults is not. Statements like "worst of nations, except for all the others", I feel, falls into the second camp.