July 25th, 2005, 1:44 pm
QuoteOriginally posted by: pyatskiWe are trying to implement an "option pricing" model for mbs which includes some parameters (to be calibrated using a prepayment model) to account for the inefficiency of the refinancing decisions. MichaelI believe it is debatable whether refinancing decisions are inefficient, as you need to take into account the various issues affecting refinancing decisions: Fixed and variable fees, possible refinancing alternatives, credit and liquidity issues etc. Empirical prepayment models provide a shortcut in the sense that past information is used to assess future prepayment behavior, thereby avoiding setting up the decision problem of the mortgagor and accounting for everything that affects these decisions. Yet it may still be a viable solution to formulate the mortgagors decisions as the result of some optimization problem, se e.g. this paper by Longstaff. Past performance is no guarantee for future returns, not even for empirical prepayment models, and decision-theoretic models may be better suited when new mortgage products are introduced