October 7th, 2006, 12:55 pm
The first method is less precise, but it gives complete prices for all possible caplets (not necessarily correct prices, however). It's useful for many analytic purposes, but not accurate enough for trading in liquid markets.The second method requires a complete set of cap prices, that is one for every payment time. If you don't have that, you have to interpolate somehow, for example using the first method but only over the interval of missing data.The first method gives you a theoretical price in a simple expression. The second method gives you an actual market price, at least to the extent your prices are good. Sometimes we want to know what something should sell for, other times we want to know what it does sell for.